How to Navigate the Workers’ Comp Audit Process

1. Preparation Is Key

  • Gather Required Documentation: Start by collecting essential records, such as:

    • Payroll reports

    • Quarterly tax reports (941s, 944s)

    • State unemployment wage reports

    • Financial statements (for some audits)

    • Employee job descriptions and classifications

  • Classify Employees Correctly: Ensure each employee is classified based on their specific job role and risk profile. Misclassifications can result in penalties or increased premiums.

  • Track Overtime Carefully: Many audits take overtime pay into account at a reduced rate, typically ⅓ less than regular pay. Be ready to provide detailed information on overtime hours and pay rates.

2. Understanding the Types of Documentation Needed

  • Payroll Records: Detailed payroll records showing gross wages for each employee, including bonuses, holiday pay, sick pay, and overtime.

  • Tax Records: Federal and state tax documents provide a verified look at payroll figures that align with what’s been reported to the government.

  • Subcontractor Information: If you work with subcontractors, you’ll need to provide details about their coverage. In many cases, subcontractors without proper insurance could be added to your payroll for Workers’ Comp calculations.

  • Certificates of Insurance (COIs) for Subcontractors: If you’ve worked with any subcontractors, you must show proof that they carry their own Workers’ Comp insurance. Without it, they may be considered part of your workforce.

3. Understand Employee Classifications

Employee classifications are integral to Workers’ Comp premiums. Here’s how to ensure you classify accurately:

  • Review Classification Codes: Check that each employee is assigned the correct classification code according to their job description. Each industry and job type has unique codes that align with risk levels, influencing premium rates.

  • Separate Clerical Workers: Clerical and administrative workers are typically at lower risk and may have separate classifications. Keeping these roles separate can reduce premium costs.

  • Track Changes in Role and Risk: If an employee changes roles or starts taking on riskier tasks, update their classification accordingly.


Steps to Simplify and Streamline the Audit Process

  1. Maintain Consistent Records Throughout the Year

    • Keeping detailed, organized payroll and job classification records throughout the policy period can help simplify the audit. Digital records are ideal, as they’re easier to access and share.

  2. Review Your Policy Periodically

    • Review your Workers’ Comp policy quarterly to make adjustments for payroll changes. Communicate significant workforce shifts, such as hiring or layoffs, to your insurer to keep estimates closer to reality.

  3. Conduct a Self-Audit Mid-Year

    • Consider performing a self-audit halfway through your policy period. By examining payroll, employee classifications, and subcontractor coverage mid-term, you can make adjustments that prevent surprises during the official audit.

  4. Seek Professional Help If Needed

    • Some companies find it beneficial to work with insurance consultants, payroll companies, or risk management advisors who specialize in Workers’ Comp audits. They can help ensure your records are audit-ready and save you time.


What Happens After the Audit?

  1. Premium Adjustment: After reviewing the audit findings, the insurance company will either bill for additional premium if payroll exceeded estimates or issue a refund if it was lower than anticipated.

  2. Audit Discrepancies: If there are discrepancies you disagree with, you can request a review or correction. Providing additional documentation can sometimes resolve disputes.

  3. Prepare for Next Year: Based on the audit findings, adjust your estimates for the upcoming policy period to avoid surprises in future audits.


Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

  1. Misclassification of Employees: This is one of the most common mistakes, often resulting in higher premiums or penalties. Regularly review job roles and consult your insurance provider if you’re unsure about classifications.

  2. Not Accounting for Seasonal Workers: If you hire temporary or seasonal employees, be sure to include them in your payroll records, and verify their classifications.

  3. Missing Subcontractor Coverage: Failing to provide subcontractor COIs can lead to additional premium charges. Always request and retain certificates from subcontractors before they begin work.

  4. Underestimating Payroll Changes: Growth in payroll due to raises, hiring, or role changes impacts the audit. Monitoring these changes and notifying your insurer can save you from a large premium adjustment at year-end.


Tips to Make Workers’ Comp Audits Easier

  1. Digitize Records: Using a payroll system or digital record-keeping solution simplifies access to the necessary documents during audits.

  2. Communicate Changes Regularly: Notify your insurer of any significant payroll or workforce changes during the year. This can help adjust your premiums to match real-time data.

  3. Review Audit Results Annually: After each audit, review your records and the insurance company’s findings. Address any issues or discrepancies early to avoid repeating mistakes.

  4. Engage with Your Insurance Provider: Many providers offer resources and support for managing Workers’ Comp policies and preparing for audits. Take advantage of any consultations or training sessions they provide.


Conclusion

Workers’ Comp audits may seem daunting, but with a proactive and organized approach, they can be manageable and straightforward. By understanding the requirements, maintaining thorough records, and preparing in advance, businesses can make the audit process smoother, ensuring compliance and potentially saving on premiums.

Navigating Workers’ Comp audits effectively demonstrates a commitment to employee safety and business transparency. With the right practices in place, you can approach each audit with confidence, knowing you’re well-prepared and informed.

Health on the Highway:Navigating wellness for truckers
Workers' Comp Insurance Explained: How Our Agency’s Unique Services Help Protect Your Business

Don’t forget to share this post

The next step is easy, call us at 405-578-5575, or click below to start your insurance quote